Comic Browser:

#0
#1
#2
#3
#4
#5
#6
#7
#8
#9
#10
#11
#12
#13
#14
#15
#16
#17
#18
#19
#20
#21
#22
#23
Selector

Avengers #1: Review

Feb 1998
Kurt Busiek, George Perez

Story Name:

Once an Avenger...

Review & Comments

Rating:
4.5 stars

Avengers #1 Review by (September 17, 2019)
Kurt Busiek is 1 of my favourite writers and bringing George Perez back to the venue of 1 of his earliest successful runs makes this a top-notch series.

Kolja Fuchs helps Richard Starkings with the lettering.

The title "Once an Avenger ..." is the opening half of a well-known quote. The 2nd half "... always an Avenger" will be used as the title of #11.
#23 of the original run had the title "Once an Avenger ..." with the implied 2nd half when Captain America returned to save the team after quitting the issue before.
The original Swordsman said the whole phrase in #100, but surely someone else got there 1st?

The chapter headings are of course parts of the semi-standard Avengers splash-page heading. Even Chapter 2's "Avengers assemble" was included in the heading's 1st appearance in #128, but later years dropped that bit.
"Avengers assemble" itself is much older. It was 1st said by Thor in #10 and was on the cover of #16.

Carol Danvers is in her Binary form here but she's wearing her last Ms Marvel costume (the blue 1 with the yellow zigzag that she will also use as Warbird). This is the 1st time she's done that, and will continue wearing the outfit through #4 as she loses her Binary powers and takes the Warbird id.

Morgan says she didn't destroy Asgard. In the closing issues of Thor's series before Heroes Reborn, Odin hid himself and the other Asgardians on Earth with Amnesia. While Thor was away in HR Journey Into Mystery #503-513 contained the Lost Gods story as the Asgardians regained their identities. But when they went to Asgard in the last issue the place was destroyed by mystery beings. The story of who these guys are will be picked up in the new Thor series.

Various other things happened in the interim too. As well as the Bannerless Hulk stories and the new (but not very long-lived) Heroes For Hire series there was also the start of the very long-lived Thunderbolts, initially Baron Zemo's Masters Of Evil pretending to be heroes to fill the Avenger void.

Morgan Le Fay was last seen in the Atlantic Rising Event where she caused the underwater city to rise to the surface as an island, killing most Atlanteans. The survivors relocated to an old city Maritanis and renamed it New Atlantis. The Marvel Chronology Project then considers her behind the scenes watching the destruction of Asgard in JIM#513 and causing the disappearance of the Norn Stones in Marvel Team-Up (1997) #4. (She'll mention those things in #3.)

Before all that Morgan was involved in the 1990 Black Knight mini-series which rescued Dane Whitman from being trapped as a statue (for the 2nd time). In that series she recruited Mordred to be her henchman. (He'd been brought to the modern age in the BK tales in Marvel UK's Hulk comic.) MCP considers he's BTS in JIM#513 too (acronyms rule OK).

Spider-Man joined the Avengers in #329 but the last issue he was actually in was #333. In fact the Avengers of the time probably spent more time in *his* comics.
Because he's wanted for murder Spidey invents 4 new identities for himself around this time. Just before this issue he became Hornet in Sensational SM#27 and Ricochet in Amazing SM#434. Following this issue is Sensational SM#28 which features an adventure of Hornet, and also cameos Captain America, Iron Man and Wasp soon after our Morgan tale concludes. Then comes SM#91 creating Dusk and Spectacular SM#257 with the 4th id Prodigy. But he still answers the Avengers' call in his regular outfit here.

Moon Knight hung around with the West Coast Avengers from #21 to #41, and for most of that time he was an official member.
Here he's between his 1998 mini-series (where he was resurrected by Khonshu to oppose other Egyptian god Seth) and Wolverine #134 (where he's 1 of many heroes, several from this issue, attacked by a possessed Logan).

Invisible Woman & Mr Fantastic were recruited by Steve Rogers (as the Captain) during the Inferno Event when the previous Avengers had disbanded. They lasted for #300-303.
The WCA invited Thing to be a member in #4 of their main series. He finally agreed at the end of #9 but quit in #10.
(At this point Human Torch has not yet been an Avenger.)
The busy Fantastic Four had already starred in their own new #1-2 (fighting foes while setting up a new base because the Thunderbolts have occupied 4 Freedoms Plaza) plus other apps since Heroes Reborn: The Return.
Next the team will be taken over by Baron Zemo in Thunderbolts #11-12 along with Cap, IM, Thor, Giant-Man, Wasp, Hawkeye, Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver of the returned Avengers (but basically a mash-up of the 1st 2 Av teams).

After their brief appearance this issue Hulk and Rick Jones return to Hulk #465 where Hulk gets a Presidential pardon (again). Everything seems to be working out fine for him (apart from Rick Jones still being crippled). But then things start to fall apart.




 

Synopsis / Summary / Plot

Avengers #1 Synopsis by Rob Johnson
The heroes (and Dr Doom) who sacrificed themselves to defeat Onslaught in the Onslaught: Marvel Universe 1-shot turned out to have been recreated in a new universe in the 4 Heroes Reborn limited series. And in the HR: The Return mini-series that was revealed to be a pocket universe subconsciously created by Franklin Richards. In that title most of our characters made it back to the 'real' Marvel universe except Thor and Doom. Thor stopped Doom's usual megalomaniacal plan by trapping them both between realities. Also, in O:MU Bruce Banner and Hulk had been separated with Banner going to the new universe and Hulk remaining on Earth-616 in his usual title. Now they are rejoined.

In our 1999 Annual Black Widow tried to gather a new team of Avengers together but failed. Then the Government revoked the Avengers charter because no founding signatories were left in the team, and they gave Avengers Mansion to SHIELD as a base.

Avengers, Captain America, Iron Man, Thor and Fantastic Four have started new series under the Heroes Return banner.

Since the return Captain America found himself inexplicably in Tokyo in the new CA#1, Hulk/Banner had a busy time in his #460-464 reuniting with Betty Ross and Rick Jones while fighting the Maestro (in the Asgardian Destroyer armour) and Armageddon of the Troyjans, Iron Man spent his 1st 3 new issues setting up a new company Stark Solutions and fighting agents of the Mandarin, and Thor Annual 1999 showed what happened to him and Doom. A confused Sub-Mariner crash-landed in Brooklyn and helped Spider-Man defeat the Wrecking Crew in Marvel Team-Up (1997) #6, and then touched base with his Oracle company in Heroes For Hire (1997) #8. And Hawkeye had his 1st run-in with the Thunderbolts (who he will soon be leading) in their #10.

This overlarge issue itself is split into chapters (like the Annuals of yore).


But 1st (as Lurcio the slave would say) the prologue:-

This issue begins with the returned Crystal and Scarlet Witch dining out in a Transian restaurant in Manhattan (Transia being Pietro and Wanda's birthplace) with Quicksilver (their husband and brother respectively) and Luna (C & Q's young daughter). Pietro's been looking after Luna in the series he started while the other 2 were away, and the 4 have already had a reunion in his #4. Quickie is complaining about the bureaucracy involved in getting someone registered as not dead (a problem which the myriad other Marvel resurrectees don't seem to worry about). Suddenly they are attacked by the Flying Trolls of Thryheim (from Tales Of Asgard in Journey Into Mystery #124-125).

At the same time in Albuquerque Firebird (Bonita Juarez) is dragged underground by Silent Trolls (from the Asgardian Isle Of Silence in the original Avengers #1). Black Panther has to fend off the dragon Nidhogg (see Thor #340) in Wakanda. In New York Hawkeye faces Mutaurus (Tales Of Asgard in Thor #143) while Magdalene and Swordsman battle carnivorous plants from Skornheim (JIM#116). Hercules meets another Asgardian dragon Ulfrin (TOA in JIM#101) in Cincinnati. And on UCLA campus Living Lightning (Miguel Santos) electrifies Rock Trolls (who also débuted in Av#1). Las Vegas sees Moondragon mindblasting Gullin the Boar God (another TOA in JIM#103). In Denver Spider-Woman (Julia Carpenter) is at the mercy of the Vanna air-sprites (this time JIM#105's TOA). Sub-Mariner punches out Kai-Ra the Rime Giant (from Thor #447) in the waters of the Scottish Hebrides. San Francisco has She-Hulk dealing with Demon Riders (TOA again, this time in Thor #141). Darkhawk battles some creatures I don't recognise in Queens, and Rage is beset by a horde of Dwarves in the Bronx but aided by Firestar and Justice.

All these ex-Avengers fight mightily until their foes vanish as suddenly as they appeared.


Chapter 1 And there came a day

There's a meeting at Avengers Mansion which SHIELD has returned to the Maria Stark Foundation. Edwin Jarvis serves tea to Cap, Giant-Man, Iron Man and Wasp as they discuss the spate of attacks. Noticeably all the attackers were Asgardian, and then an exhausted Thor comes crashing through a window to tell them the world is in dire peril. The 5 of them renew their vow to help each other as Avengers, and they send out the call ...


Chapter 2 Avengers assemble


Hawkeye slides down to the Mansion gates on an arrow-line, and meets Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver getting out of a taxi. Jarvis welcomes them in to find that they are the last arrivals. Even Crystal got there before them. All the ex-Avengers who were attacked are there. Firestar and Justice aren't Avengers but they accompanied Rage. Other Avengers Beast, Binary (ex-Ms Marvel), Black Knight, Black Widow, Demolition Man, Falcon, Photon, Quasar, Sandman, Sersi, Spider-Man, Starfox, Stingray, Tigra, U.S. Agent and Vision have rallied to the call. Honorary Avenger Rick Jones is in his floating 'wheel chair' (he was injured in Hulk #456 by the Bannerless Hulk under the control of Apocalypse as 1 of his 4 Horsemen).

Some chars have sent their apologies. James Rhodes is no longer War Machine (in the Tales Of The Marvel Universe 1-shot he sacrificed the Warwear armour to keep Tony Stark's Iron Man Technology from Fujikawa Inc who had taken over Stark Enterprises). Jim Hammond, the WWII android Human Torch, is busy running Oracle Inc and the new Heroes For Hire. Deathcry went back to the Shi'ar in #399.

Black Widow considers herself responsible for the demise of the team. Various members comment of D-Man's smell (he's living with the homeless residents of the underground Zero-Town). Justice and Firestar think they shouldn't be here because they've never been Avengers.

The founding members aren't with the group. They are speaking to the Fantastic Four because 3 of them (not their Human Torch) *have* been Avengers, but they can't make it. Angry Hulk contacts *them* to say he was attacked by Trolls but he doesn't want to have anything to do with their problems. Iron Man surveys the screenful of other missing members and declares them dead (original Captain Marvel, Dr Druid, Gilgamesh, Hellcat, Jocasta, Marrina, Mockingbird, original Swordsman (Jacques Duquesne), Thunderstrike, Yellowjacket (Rita DeMara)), in another time (original Guardians Of The Galaxy, Two-Gun Kid), or uncontactible (Mantis, Masque, Moon Knight). So they go to join the others.


Chapter 3 A common threat

Temporary chairman Cap gives a stirring speech, but then he intends to hand over to Thor who knows more about what's happening. Hawkeye whispers to Scarlet Witch that *they* should be on the podium with the founders - they've been Avengers almost as long and they've both been team leaders (of the West Coast Avengers and Force Works). Spider-Man interrupts to say that he'll have to leave them to it because it seems like he's handling 5 different problems at once (a joking reference to his 5 regular titles Amazing, Sensational, Spectacular and plain SM plus Marvel Team-Up). Cap excuses him to go deal with his legal troubles (the recently-returned Norman Osborn has Spidey accused of murder since SM#88). The alternate-timeline Swordsman (Philip Javert) accuses him of cowardice, and ex-Spidey villain Sandman leaps to his defence.

Thor explains how in Heroes Reborn: The Return #4 he fought Dr Doom to stop him from using Franklin Richards to gain control over the Heroes Reborn pocket universe. He used Mjolnir to trap them both between universes. He doesn't remember what happened next but he awoke in a devastated, empty Asgard with a broken Rainbow Bridge. Indeed all the other Asgardian Realms were empty too. And on the shores of the Sea Of Eternal Night the huge Twilight Sword was missing. But he did find a fragment of Bifrost, and touching it transported him to Chicago in Midgard.

As he learned of the attacks by Asgardian beings Thor deduced that other fragments of the Bridge had landed in the other Realms allowing their inhabitants to reach Earth. But if whoever caused this has the Sword then they can destroy or remake the universe. He explains that the Twilight Sword was forged by Surtur in the heart of the Burning Galaxy (beginning in Thor #337). After Surtur was defeated it was placed in the Sea Of EN (Thor #425) where Surtur and Ymir were trapped fighting over it.

The Thunder God also believes the 5 Norn Stones (see lots of Thor issues starting with JIM#116) have been stolen too, and he can sense them scattered in 5 areas of Midgard. So they need to split into 5 teams to retrieve the stones. Justice interrupts to say it's probably a trap, and then realises everybody else already figured that out. But they're going anyway.

5 quinjets fly away from the Mansion. Rick Jones is left behind with Jarvis, and they feed Black Knight's winged horse Aragorn. Moon Knight has been listening in, but he's no longer a team player. But someone else is observing the proceedings with evil intent.


Chapter 4 To fight the foes

Cap's team (Crystal, Demolition Man, Hercules, Quasar, Quicksilver and Scarlet Witch) head to Tintagel in Cornwall. A sudden cyclone throws their quinjet around. Steve Rogers sends Quasar outside, using his power to support Crystal in midair as she uses *her* elemental powers to try to quell the storm. Meanwhile Black Panther reports that *his* team has found some opposition, but that Thor says that the other 4 Norn Stones have now moved to Tintagel too.

Crystal's efforts aren't working so Wanda Maximoff leans out of the jet held by Hercules and adds her hex/magic power to the mix. And the cyclone twists away. She tells the others she felt a personality in the wind, and she *commanded* it to go away. (It will be suggested that the personality was that of the villainess who we'll meet at the end of the issue.)

With the air clear they see that the giant Twilight Sword is buried nearly to the hilt in the ruins of Tintagel Castle. They land. Hercules complains about D-Man's smell but Cap tells him to leave his friend alone. Steve asks about Zero-Town. Dennis Dunphy says they're OK but they need all the water they've got for drinking and there's none left for washing.

Suddenly they are greeted by Mordred, bastard son of King Arthur. And equally-suddenly at his finger-snap the ground exudes earthen tentacles which pull Scarlet Witch down. He thanks the team for bringing then what they wanted. And the ground creates genuine rock Trolls to battle them. The others keep them busy while Pietro Maximoff rushes over to punch Mordred. The villain falls among the near-mindless Trolls and so banishes them before they turn on *him*. Quicksilver then threatens Mordred and demands to know where his sister is.

But Mordred suggests they ask his mistress. And a figure manifests who bookworm Quasar recognises from the Avengers files as Morgan Le Fay (see #240-241), Mordred's aunt. It's less obvious how he knows she's wearing the Norn Stones as a necklace. But she provides the usual villain explanation of her plot.

Black Widow's team (Firestar, Justice, Magdalene, Rage, Sandman, Sersi and Swordsman) are fighting the Midgard Serpent in the South Pacific. Wasp's team (Black Knight, Giant-Man, Photon, She-Hulk, Starfox, Stingray and Sub-Mariner) battle Frost Giants in the Arctic. Iron Man leads Darkhawk, Firebird, Living Lightning, Machine Man, Spider-Woman, Tigra and US Agent against the Celtic evil gods the Fomor in Equatorial Africa. And Panther's group (Beast, Falcon, Hawkeye, Moondragon, Thor and Vision) are in Central America facing reanimated Conquistador skeletons. (I don't see Binary anywhere.)

But all of this, and Mordred's Trolls, were a distraction. Morgan's Celtic heritage is similar enough to the Asgardian Dark Elves for her to use the Norn Stones, but not to control the Twilight Sword. For that she needed the Scarlet Witch. The plan was to weaken the Avengers by splitting them up, and then whichever team included Wanda would be the main target. Now that she has her Morgan can use the Witch's reality-warping power to link her Celtic magic with the Asgardian Sword.

Morgan grasps the hilt and draws the sword. Wanda screams and Pietro rushes to her side. But Le Fay brandishes the sword and everything goes white ...


George Perez
Al Vey
Tom Smith
George Perez (Cover Penciler)
George Perez (Cover Inker)
Tom Smith (Cover Colorist)
Letterer: Richard Starkings.
Editor: Tom Brevoort. Editor-in-chief: Bob Harras.

Characters

Listed in Alphabetical Order.

Black Widow
Black Widow

(Natasha Romanoff)
Captain America
Captain America

(Steve Rogers)
Giant-Man
Giant-Man

(Hank Pym)
Hawkeye
Hawkeye

(Clint Barton)
Iron Man
Iron Man

(Tony Stark)
Jarvis
Jarvis

(Edwin Jarvis)
Quasar
Quasar

(Wendell Vaughn)
Quicksilver
Quicksilver

(Pietro Maximoff)
Scarlet Witch
Scarlet Witch

(Wanda Maximoff)
Thor
Thor

(Odinson)
Wasp
Wasp

(Janet Van Dyne)

Plus: Binary (Carol Danvers), D-Man (Demolition Man), Firestar (Angel Jones), Justice (Vance Astrovik), Mordred, Morgana Le Fey (Morgan Le Fay).

> Avengers: Book info and issue index

Share This Page


Elektra