Previous Page   Next Page
#196
#197
#198
#199
#200
#201
#307
#324
#513
#514
#540
#541
#542
#543
Selector

Uncanny X-Men, The (1981 series) #201

on-sale: Oct 8, 1985
Chris Claremont | Rick Leonardi

Uncanny X-Men, The (1981 series) #201 cover

Story Name:

Duel


Synopsis

Uncanny X-Men, The (1981 series) #201 synopsis by Anthony Silvestro
Rating: 4.5 stars

The X-Men return from Paris to discover that Madelyne has had her baby; she and Cyclops are now parents! The various members marvel at the wonders of new life and Nightcrawler jokes that the baby will be just fine taking after him. Rachel tips the chair Kurt’s on over causing him to retaliate by mercilessly tickling her, as everyone else looks on in amusement. Madelyne hands her new baby to Kitty so that she can talk to Storm in private. Madelyne asks about Professor Xavier and Storm confirms that it seems he won’t be coming back. Madelyne then vents her frustrations, having had to give birth alone at the mansion, as well as how distant Scott has been lately. When the X-Men were in Paris, practically everyone else called to check up on her, except her husband. Meanwhile, Rachel starts to bond with her new sibling (still unbeknownst to Scott) and Kitty points out that she should tell him the truth soon. Outside, Scott has his own worries, wondering why the Professor isn’t here to celebrate this milestone with him, while still worried that Magneto can’t be trusted.

Speaking of Professor Xavier, we find him deep in space, aboard the Starjammers’ ship. After beaming him up in order to save his life last issue, Corsair reveals that they don’t have the power to send him back to Earth! And with their ship currently damaged and on the run, they may never be able to get him back to Earth! Xavier reflects on all of this with Lilandra, worried for his various students. Deciding they can only worry about what is right now, Xavier decides to make the best of things and stay in space with Lilandra. Back at the school, life goes on as usual. Cannonball faces problems writing a term paper and the X-Men decide to play some baseball outside. Nightcrawler discusses with Wolverine the issues that seem to be going on with Scott, wondering how it’s going to affect the team. Colossus ends up hitting a ball high into the sky causing Rogue to have to fly way up to catch it. She snags it just before it hits Air Force One, leaving a cheeky kiss on the window for the President!

LEGO Marvel Fantastic Four vs. Galactus (300x250)
Excelsioring your collection

Later, Scott and Madelyne end up borrowing Storm’s attic to sort through a domestic fight. Scott is adamant he needs to stay and lead the team and Madelyne can’t fathom why, especially with their new baby. Madelyne posits that he’s afraid that the X-Men no longer need him, his entire sense of self-worth having been tied to the team for so long. She says that her commitment to him supersedes everything else and when she asks if the same holds true for him…Scott has no answer. Storm says that a decision must be made and suggests a duel between herself and Scott to determine who gets to lead the X-Men moving forward. Cyclops and Storm then kick Magneto and the New Mutants out of the Danger Room so they can have their duel, while everyone else piles into the command room to watch.

After a holographic area is constructed, the duel begins and Cyclops takes the offensive, wanting to end it quickly. Storm ducks behind some cover and is able to take Cyclops by surprise momentarily before he drives her off again. In the command room, Wolverine is clearly rooting for Storm, pointing out that Scott’s heart really isn’t in it anymore. While the duel goes on, Madelyne sits with her baby, hoping that her husband loses so he won’t have any reason to stay. Back in the Danger Room, the duel ends when Storm is able to snag Cyclops’ visor, leaving him effectively helpless without hurting everyone. Storm is declared the winner and Cyclops congratulates her, while inside he feels utterly crushed, realizing there’s truly no place for him there anymore. In an epilogue, Rachel visits her grandparents’ house in the dead of night. She adds some of her own essence to the Matrix Crystal of Jean that was given to them by the Shi’ar. On the moon, something happens at the spot where Jean Grey sacrificed herself all those years ago and the Watcher looks on with fascination! Rachel leaves the crystal with her grandparents, hoping she’ll be remembered as she sets out to try and slay the Beyonder!


INCREDIBLE HULK EPIC COLLECTION: THE CURING OF DR. BANNER
Excelsioring your collection


Characters
Good (or All)
CANNONBALL
COLOSSUS
CYCLOPS
KPRYDE
LILANDRA
MAGNETO
NIGHTCRAWLER
XAVIER
RSUMMERS
ROGUE
STORM
WATCHER
WOLVERINE
XMEN
Plus: Binary (Carol Danvers), Corsair (Christopher Summers), Madelyne Pryor, Nathan Summers (Baby), New Mutants, Starjammers.


> Uncanny X-Men, The (1981 series) comic book info and issue index



Incredible Hulk Epic Collection: Devolution
Excelsioring your collection

Main/1st Story Full Credits

Rick Leonardi
Whilce Portacio
Glynis Oliver
Rick Leonardi (Cover Penciler)
Whilce Portacio (Cover Inker)
Unknown (Cover Colorist)
Additional Credits
Letterer: Tom Orzechowski.



Review / Commentaries


Uncanny X-Men, The (1981 series) #201 Review by (August 20, 2025)

Review: This issue is actually extremely significant for a number of reasons! First off, after what felt like the shortest pregnancy in history, Madelyne has her and Scott’s baby (technically born between issues)! That makes this kind of Cable’s first appearance? Some sources seem to count it, and some tend to only count the issue where he first appears as Cable. Scott can’t enjoy his new fatherhood however, feeling he needs to stay and lead the team. This causes him and Storm to have a duel to determine who gets to be the leader and Storm ends up winning. This crushes Scott, whose whole sense of identity had been tied to the X-Men for so long that apparently even having a wife and child doesn’t help. This is all to serve the upcoming start of the X-Factor series the following month, in which Scott discovers Jean Grey is still alive and forms X-Factor with the other original X-Men. Chris Claremont was famously unhappy with this direction, not wanting Jean to be brought back, as it ended up derailing everything he had been doing with Scott. However, he was overruled and forced to set things up here. This had the added effect of this being Cyclops at his most unlikeable (at least during Claremont’s tenure) seeing as he clearly cares more about the X-Men than his wife and child (and in fact he’d end up effectively abandoning them after reuniting with Jean, something Claremont really didn’t like and I don’t blame him).

The last thing of significance is Xavier being forced to stay in space with Starjammers. He’d been beamed up to their ship last issue to be saved from death and they discover that they have no way to get him back to Earth. It always felt like they tried to find a way to hinder or remove Xavier practically every storyline, often not knowing what to do with him or fearing he’d too easily solve whatever issue they were facing. This is kind of odd, given how Xavier is one the more central X-Men characters but looking back at Claremont’s tenure up to this point, he never really did all that much, for the aforementioned reasons. Having him stay in space with Lilandra ultimately serves to mitigate this by just removing him from the series entirely, making this one of his last appearances in Uncanny X-Men for a long time! I think he’s gone for a good 5 or 6 years, real time, only popping up here and there in various series but never consistently! This issue then ends with more teases at Jean’s return (more set up for X-Factor) and leads into more Secret Wars II tie-in stuff, as Rachel decides to try and kill the Beyonder!

Comments: Nathan Summers is born (technically between issues, and goes unnamed as of this issue). With that, first appearance of Cable (depending on who you ask). Professor Xavier decides to stay in space, making it his last appearance for a long time. Storm officially wins the right to lead the X-Men once more. Guest appearance by then-President Ronald Reagan.





Thor

The Marvel Heroes Library is a fan Marvel Comics site
Version 14.9.12 (Aug 19, 2025 - VS22)

Copyright © 1997-2025 Julio Molina-Muscara (creator, webmaster)
Site content is a collective effort by the MHL team and Marvel aficionados

Characters are copyright © Marvel or their respective owners. All portions of this Marvel fansite that are subject to copyright are licensed under a creative commons attribution 3.0 unported license All rights reserved